Garrett County Commissioners Recognize Brenda’s Pizzeria and Trader’s Coffee House for 25 Years in Business

The Garrett County Commissioners presented 25th anniversary proclamations to Brenda’s Pizzeria and Trader’s Coffee House during their public meeting on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, recognizing a significant milestone for two locally established businesses that have become fixtures in the Deep Creek Lake community.

Owned by Brenda McDonnell, the two businesses have been serving Garrett County residents and visitors since 2001, building a reputation for quality, hospitality, and a welcoming atmosphere.

Brenda’s Pizzeria is known for its New York-style pizza, made-from-scratch dough, homemade sauces, and extensive menu of Italian favorites. Located at Trader’s Landing along Garrett Highway, the restaurant has become a popular gathering place for families, residents, and visitors enjoying the Deep Creek Lake area.

Trader’s Coffee House has developed its own following, offering specialty coffee drinks, espresso beverages, breakfast and lunch options, and an assortment of freshly prepared bakery items. With an emphasis on quality ingredients, in-house baking, and locally sourced products whenever possible, the coffee house has become a favorite stop for both locals and tourists.

Over the past 25 years, both businesses have continued to evolve, investing in their facilities, expanding their offerings, adapting to changing customer needs, and creating employment opportunities. Their success also extends beyond their own operations through support of local farmers, producers, community organizations, and other area businesses.

"Reaching a 25-year milestone is a significant accomplishment, particularly in the competitive restaurant and hospitality industry, said Kim Durst, Manager of Business Development for Garrett County Government. "Sustaining a business for that length of time requires hard work, sound business decisions, a willingness to adapt, and a commitment to serving customers and the community. We congratulate Brenda and her team on this milestone and thank them for their continued investment in our community."

The recognition also highlights the importance of business development in Garrett County. Locally owned businesses are an essential part of the county's economic foundation. They create jobs, generate economic activity, attract visitors, support other local businesses, and contribute to the character and quality of life that make Garrett County a desirable place to live, work, and visit.

Business development is not solely about attracting new companies to the county. It is equally important to support existing businesses as they grow, reinvest, create employment opportunities, and navigate the challenges of operating in an evolving economy. Businesses like Brenda’s Pizzeria and Trader’s Coffee House demonstrate the long-term value of entrepreneurship and the positive impact that sustained business investment can have on a community.

A program administered by Garrett County's Department of Business Development, the Garrett County Milestone Recognition Program celebrates local businesses reaching significant anniversaries and recognizes their lasting contributions to the county's economy and community. Businesses interested in learning more about the Milestone Recognition Program may contact our office at (301) 334-1921.
 

Photo credit: Claudia Reynolds, The Garrett County Republican.

Created 11/18/2026 1:31pm
Last Updated 11/20/2026 12:07pm